Imagine a place where the rustic charm of a local eatery meets the bold flair of modern cuisine. Welcome to Billy Goat 9 & Dine, nestled in the heart of New Carlisle, Indiana, precisely at 755 W Michigan St. It's not just a restaurant; it’s a cozy gathering spot where food, laughter, and community collide beautifully.
Upon entry, the ambiance is both welcoming and unassuming. At first glance, Billy Goat 9 & Dine may seem like your typical, quaint roadside eatery, but the menu tells a different story. Here, the classics mingle with exciting innovations; this duality is a major draw for both locals and visitors alike. Those who have a penchant for hearty meals are in for a treat. There's talk around town that their signature Goat Burger is a culinary masterpiece in itself - a juicy, perfectly seasoned patty crowned with a medley of toppings that just scream 'satisfaction'. Pair it with a side of crispy fries and there's not much more one could wish for in a meal.
The restaurant doesn't stop at just serving dinner delights. Breakfast and brunch options here are more than worth the mention. Fluffy pancakes served with warm maple syrup or savory omelets that ooze flavor make waking up early seem like a pretty good decision. And oh, for those with a sweet tooth, the dessert selection demands a taste. The homemade pies are nothing short of legendary in these parts.
Conveniently situated on W Michigan Street, getting to Billy Goat 9 & Dine is as easy as pie. A perfect pitstop for travelers and a regular haunt for the local crowd, it has developed quite the reputation. Online reviews echo this sentiment, with patrons often singing praises of the hospitable staff and the consistency in quality. One diner was quite effusive about the level of detail put into every dish, ensuring a delightful experience each time.
For those who may have frequented this charming spot, perhaps it’s the ambiance or the warm service that keeps drawing them back. Or maybe it's the irresistible allure of trying something new from a menu that continues to surprise and delight. Whatever the reason, Billy Goat 9 & Dine effortlessly encapsulates the essence of a memorable dining experience.
Features & Amenities
Service Options
Outdoor seating
Takeout
Dine-in
Delivery
Highlights
Fast service
Great beer selection
Great cocktails
Serves local specialty
Sports
Popular For
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining
Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Wheelchair accessible restroom
Wheelchair accessible seating
Offerings
Alcohol
Beer
Cocktails
Coffee
Comfort food
Happy hour drinks
Happy hour food
Hard liquor
Healthy options
Late-night food
Quick bite
Small plates
Wine
Dining Options
Lunch
Dinner
Dessert
Seating
Table service
Amenities
Bar onsite
Restroom
Atmosphere
Casual
Cozy
Trendy
Crowd
Family-friendly
Groups
Tourists
Planning
Accepts reservations
Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Children
Good for kids
High chairs
Kids' menu
Parking
Free parking lot
Free street parking
Usually plenty of parking
Reviews
Average Rating
4.3/5
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5/5 — Nick Tortorelli
Staff was extremely friendly. Owner was walking around talking to patrons. Very down to earth local spot for a bite to eat or just a social get together. Food was excellent! The cheese curds were amazing and not like I’d had anywhere else before. Reuben was cooked to perfection.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5/5 — Katie B
Tried this place for the first time yesterday and we really enjoyed it! I had a lovely glass of pinot grigio with 'Just the Tip' appetizer (deep fried asparagus tips) to start. They were delicious! 👌 My brother decided to get the Mac wrap and it looked sooo good! It was definitely a good serving! He ate it all and said it was great! The fries were absolutely amazing! If you ask to get them extra crispy they are like chips! I enjoyed a byo bunless burger with mayo, cheese, bacon and a fried egg with cottage cheese. Everything was fresh, delicious and the waitress and bartender were phenomenal and lovely! My boyfriend and I are going back this evening and trying some other dishes! Can't wait! Went back the next day for dinner. Busy busy! We both got the fish. He got lake perch and tots and I got the fried cod with fries and coleslaw. Everything was delicious! Can't wait to go back!
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5/5 — Jared Martin
Really liked it here! It's sort of tucked into the back lot, so it's kinda hidden away, but the food was great, and I really liked the atmosphere and service! I would definitely go back.
⭐⭐⭐⭐ 4/5 — Anthony Holland (Tony)
Our waitress was so nice and understanding, and she took great care of us. The food was good and the location is perfect.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5/5 — Rufus Reviews
Ordered Togo today. This place is back on top. Fresh food. Done in the time they quoted. I want these local businesses to thrive. This is the MOST reliable restaurant in town. They are always open. They stay open. They welcome you when you walk in. Just happy with quality of service. At times they go through bad cooks or short staff. They always come out on top. Thanks Billy Goat.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5/5 — Shaun Krenzke
Always a great meal. Sometimes it's busy, but they do offer an order in advance option, if you call - especially, for pizzas and such that may take longer to cook.
⭐⭐⭐⭐ 4/5 — Albert Alvarez
Great view and good food. When it gets really busy, the servers can at times forget about you. Definitely shouldn’t go during peak hours when in a hurry.
Give Us Your Honest Feedback
Contact
Phone: (574) 654-7311
Address: 755 W Michigan St, New Carlisle, IN 46552